Volvo S40 Problems: Owner Reports, Recalls and Parts

|
10 min read
Indicative studio image of a used alternator, an in-tank fuel pump with its electronic module, a brake master cylinder and a power steering hose

TL;DR

The S40 is our most-enquired Volvo. Here is what owners ask us for, the fuel pump module and sunroof-drain faults US owners report, and five recalls to check.

If you own a second-generation Volvo S40, you are in good company on this site. Since 17 February 2026 we have logged 2,746 parts enquiries, and 484 of them were for an S40, more than for any other Volvo. This guide puts what those owners ask us for next to what the US government's vehicle-safety database records about the same car: the fuel pump module that can strand you, water that gets in through the sunroof drains, a "KEY ERROR" no-start, and five recalls worth checking against your VIN.

We are an independent used-parts supplier and are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or authorised by Volvo Car Corporation or AB Volvo.

Call 031 943 9999

Volvo S40 · the numbers behind this guide

484

S40 enquiries on this site since 17 Feb 2026, the most for any model

Source: our enquiry log

205

owner complaints filed in the US for 2005 to 2011 S40s

Source: NHTSA, our count

5

US safety recalls covered below, from fuel lines to brakes

Source: NHTSA recall records

In this guide
  1. How we built this guide
  2. What S40 owners ask us for
  3. Stalls or won't start: the fuel pump module
  4. "KEY ERROR TRY AGAIN"
  5. Water on the floor, then electrical chaos
  6. Five recalls to check against your VIN
  7. What to send us when you ask for a price

How we built this guide

Most "S40 problems" pages are written from memory. We used two sets of records instead. The first is our own enquiry log: every request that names an S40, read on 22 November 2026, with names and contact details left out. The second is the complaints and recalls database run by NHTSA, the US road-safety regulator, where owners file reports in their own words.1

Read the US figures for what they are. NHTSA complaints are reports written by owners, and the recalls are US campaigns. A raw count is not a failure rate, and a US recall does not tell you whether a South African car was included. Ask a Volvo dealer to check your car's VIN for open campaigns.

What S40 owners ask us for

500 enquiries in our log mention an S40, either as the chosen model or in the part description. Here is what they named. We sorted them by searching the part description, so one enquiry can count under two headings.

Part named in the enquiryS40 enquiries
Gearbox or transmission parts (used gearboxes, clutch, valve body, gear shifter)42
Suspension (shocks, struts, control arms, bushes, coilovers)34
Alternator28
Turbo18
Brake parts (pads, discs, calipers, master cylinder)18
Mirrors15
Tail lights14
Cooling (radiators, hoses, water pumps)13
Wiring harness11
Fuel pump9
Headlights8
Starter7

Gearboxes and alternators sit near the top. Thirty enquiries used the word gearbox or transmission and 28 named an alternator. Engine requests are spread across blocks, heads, bearings, harnesses and complete engines, so we have not lumped them into one row.

Indicative studio image of a used car alternator with a multi-groove pulley
Indicative image of an alternator.

Related parts

S40 alternators

One of the S40 parts our customers ask for most. Send the engine size and year, or the VIN, and we will match the right unit for your car. See the S40 alternator page for fitment details.

Stalls or won't start: the fuel pump electronic module

One S40 fault has both owner complaints and a recall behind it: the pump electronic module, or PEM, which controls the fuel pump. NHTSA's record of Volvo's recall 08V033 explains that after long exposure to "salty-wet conditions, it is possible for the pump electronic module (PEM) to become corroded internally. This can cause a faulty signal to the fuel pump, resulting in low or no fuel pressure to the engine."2

That campaign covered 2004 to 2006 S40s sold or registered in a list of US states, and the fix was to "replace the PEM and install it in a new location to prevent corrosion."2 We cannot tell you whether a South African car had the same work done, so treat the PEM as a suspect rather than a certainty.

Owners describe it plainly. One 2005 owner reported: "Fuel pump control module (PEM) fails during wet conditions. Car will crank like normal but will not start. Let car dry out for a few days and then the car will run normal again." Another owner's report says the car "stalled without warning", and the mechanic it was towed to "diagnosed that the fuel pump electronic module had failed due to rusting and corrosion."1 We counted 9 complaints for 2005 to 2011 S40s that mention the module by name.

Don't buy a fuel pump on a guess. A car that cranks but won't fire, and recovers after drying out, points at the module before the pump. Ask your workshop to say which one they condemned.

Indicative studio image of an in-tank fuel pump assembly
Indicative image of a fuel pump assembly.

Related parts

S40 fuel pumps and pump modules

Tell us whether the workshop condemned the pump itself or the electronic module, and we will quote the right part. Browse S40 fuel pumps.

"KEY ERROR TRY AGAIN"

A smaller cluster of complaints describes a dashboard message rather than a mechanical failure. A 2005 S40 T5 owner wrote that the display will show "Key error try again." When this happens the car will not start at all.1 We found 4 complaints with that message, all on 2005 cars.

The complaints do not agree on a cause, so we won't guess one. If your S40 shows it, have an auto-electrician read the stored fault codes before any module is replaced. Then send us the code and the part they name.

Water on the floor, then electrical chaos

This is the pattern we would watch for on any S40 with a sunroof. We counted 12 complaints that link the sunroof to water in the car. A 2005 owner reported water "soaking the floor mats behind the driver's seat".1 A 2006 owner described the "passenger rear floor flooding continuously" until the dealer "stated clogged sunroof drain", and by then the car had "no power windows or locks".3 Another wrote that water "leaked into my vehicle through the sunroof, destroyed the computer and air airbag system."3

Common mistake: replacing modules while the floor is still wet. If windows, locks and warning lights are acting up together after rain, lift the rear carpets first. A new module in a damp footwell is money spent twice.

Owners also mention smaller electrical faults. One 2005 owner reported "3 of the 4 door lock actuators on my car have stopped working."1 A 2009 owner changing headlight bulbs found the covering around the "electrical wiring harness which connect to headlight crumbled in my hands".4 We carry S40 wiring harnesses and S40 headlights for repairs like these.

Five recalls to check against your VIN

NHTSA lists more S40 campaigns than these, including one for a power passenger seat stop. We have kept to the five that bear on parts we supply. The wording in the last column is NHTSA's summary, shortened.

CampaignS40 model years listedPartWhat NHTSA's record says
06V1372004 to 2006Fuel line (T5 turbo engines)The polyamide fuel line tube near the turbo and exhaust manifold is sensitive to extreme heat. Dealers changed the material to Teflon.2
08V0332004 to 2006Pump electronic moduleInternal corrosion in salty-wet conditions can cut fuel pressure. Covered cars in named US states.2
08V1012007Brake master cylinderA soft anodised layer can wear a rubber seal and leak brake fluid internally. The campaign covered 1,114 MY2007 C30, C70, S40 and V50 cars.5
08V3292008 to 2009Power steering return hoseA hose section was not properly cured. A rupture can mean a complete loss of power assistance.6
11V1862011Engine-bay support memberA crack may have formed on the passenger-side support member during production.7

If one of these parts has failed on your car and a dealer confirms there is no open campaign for it, that is where we can help. Brakes are the one to take seriously. NHTSA's record of the master cylinder campaign describes braking that deteriorates gradually, "forcing the driver to use a higher than expected force on the brake pedal".5 If your pedal needs more effort than it used to, have the brakes checked before you drive on.

Indicative studio image of a brake master cylinder with its fluid reservoir
Indicative image of a brake master cylinder.

Related parts

S40 brake master cylinders

Send the year or the VIN and we will check fitment. More on the S40 master cylinder page.

What to send us when you ask for a price

  • The VIN or the year and engine, so we match the right part first time.
  • The part the workshop condemned, in their words: fuel pump or pump module, alternator, harness.
  • Any fault codes that were read, exactly as they appeared.

Parts are pulled in Durban North and couriered nationwide. Start from the Volvo S40 parts page or send your request with the button below.

Frequently asked questions

Is the Volvo S40 a reliable car?

We don't have a reliability score to give you, and we won't invent one. What the records show is a handful of repeat faults rather than one big weakness: the fuel pump electronic module, water getting in through blocked sunroof drains, and a "KEY ERROR" no-start reported on 2005 cars. Check the recalls against the VIN and look for a damp rear footwell before you buy.

Which year was the Volvo S40 best?

We can't name a best year from the data we have. The US complaint counts are highest for 2005 and 2006 cars, but a raw count reflects how many were sold and how long they have been on the road, not just how good they were. Judge the car in front of you on its service history, its recall status and a dry interior.

What causes a Volvo S40 not to start?

Two patterns stand out in owner complaints. One is the fuel pump electronic module: the car cranks but won't fire, sometimes recovering once it dries out. The other is a "KEY ERROR TRY AGAIN" message with no start at all. Have the fault codes read before buying parts, then send us the code and the part named.

Sources

  1. NHTSA (US National Highway Traffic Safety Administration), owner complaints for the 2005 Volvo S40 (raw data). We ran the same query for each model year from 2005 to 2011 for the counts in this guide, read 22 November 2026.
  2. NHTSA, recall records for the 2004 Volvo S40, including campaigns 08V033 (pump electronic module) and 06V137 (fuel line).
  3. NHTSA, owner complaints for the 2006 Volvo S40.
  4. NHTSA, owner complaints for the 2009 Volvo S40.
  5. NHTSA, recall records for the 2007 Volvo S40, campaign 08V101 (brake master cylinder).
  6. NHTSA, recall records for the 2008 Volvo S40, campaign 08V329 (power steering return hose).
  7. NHTSA, recall records for the 2011 Volvo S40, campaign 11V186 (engine-bay support member).

Need Volvo Parts?

Quality-tested spares for all models, delivered nationwide with warranty included.

Disclaimer: Volvo Spares Scrap Yard is an independent used parts supplier and is not affiliated with Volvo Car Corporation. Information in this article is provided for general guidance only.